Property settlements
Caldwell & Caldwell: when an inherited family trust is property
Part 1 of our series: Family trusts and separation
The short answer
In Caldwell & Caldwell [2026] FedCFamC1A 81, the Full Court held, by two judges to one, that three discretionary trusts set up by the husband’s father were the husband’s property for a property settlement. What mattered was that he could take control of the trusts and benefit himself, even though he had never done so and neither spouse had built the assets. The decision does not say what share, if any, the wife will receive.
The family and the trusts
Caldwell is a pseudonym. The family business was started in the early 1900s by the husband’s great-grandfather and passed down through four generations. The husband’s father set up three discretionary trusts between 1982 and 2016. While he was alive, he was the only appointor of each trust and held the only voting shares in the companies that acted as trustee.
The husband worked in the business all his adult life and was well paid. Neither he nor the wife had received distributions directly from the trusts, although he had received loans from them that were later forgiven. From 2019, anyone who was not a direct descendant of the husband’s father was shut out of the trusts. The wife, who had earlier been a possible beneficiary of two of them, was excluded.
The couple separated in early 2022. The husband’s father died later that year. Under his will, the voting shares in the trustee companies passed to the husband and the couple’s two adult sons jointly, and the three of them became joint appointors of the trusts.
What could the husband do?
On paper, control was shared between the husband and his sons. Two details changed that. Where a share was held jointly, only the vote of the first-named holder counted, and the husband was named first. And although the appointors had to act together, the husband could remove either or both of his sons as appointors at any time, without giving reasons, and choose their replacements.
The result was that he could decide who the trustee was. Each deed gave the trustee a wide discretion to pay income or capital to any beneficiary, and the husband was a beneficiary.
What was the Court asked?
The wife asked the Court to decide one question before the rest of the case: are the trusts, or their assets, property of the husband for the purposes of section 79 of the Family Law Act? The husband accepted that the trusts were a financial resource of his, which is a weaker category, but said they were not his property.
In July 2025 the trial judge agreed with the husband. She found that the trusts existed to keep the family business in the hands of the father’s descendants, that the assets had been built by four generations and not by the couple, and that the husband had never used the trusts as his own. The couple also had property outside the trusts, estimated at between $16 million and $22 million.
What did the majority decide?
On 11 May 2026 Justices Christie and Brasch allowed the wife’s appeal and declared that the three trusts, or their assets, are the husband’s property for the purposes of section 79.
- Two questions, not one. Whether something is property comes first. What share each person should receive comes later. The trial judge had run the two together.
- Control and the ability to benefit. The husband could take control of the trustee, and the deeds let the trustee pay him. That placed the trusts within the established meaning of property in family law.
- Control does not have to be used. It was enough that nothing stood in the way of the husband taking control. He did not need to have done it.
- Where the assets came from is a contributions question. It matters when the Court weighs what each person contributed. It does not decide whether the trust is property.
- The purpose argument failed. The deeds allowed the husband to benefit himself, so doing so could not be an improper use of his powers. A statement of the father’s wishes in a 2021 codicil to his will could not change the purpose of deeds made years earlier.
- Intentions were beside the point. During the case the husband agreed with his sons to give up his power to remove them. The question was what control he held, not what he planned to do with it.
What did the dissenting judge say?
Justice Strum would have dismissed the appeal. In his view, control and the ability to benefit are necessary but are not enough. The earlier cases all had something more: assets the couple had built, a trust set up during the marriage, or a history of one spouse treating the trust as their own. None of that was present here. He also considered that the husband did not yet have control, because he would first have to push his sons aside, and that the wife was asking the Court to create property that did not exist.
What does the decision not decide?
- It does not decide what the wife receives. The majority said that a finding of property does not mean an adjustment from that property will follow. That is for the trial judge.
- It does not make every family trust property. The majority accepted that some trusts holding generational wealth may not be property of a spouse. These trusts were, because of the control the husband held.
- It does not change the position of a person who cannot control a trust. A beneficiary with no say over the trustee is in a different position.
The High Court declined to hear it
Two applications were made to the High Court for special leave to appeal, one of them by the trustees. On 10 September 2026 the High Court refused both, with costs, saying the case was not a suitable vehicle for the questions raised. The Full Court’s decision stands.
A refusal of special leave is not a ruling that the Full Court was right, so the disagreement between the judges may be argued again in another case.
Why does it matter?
For a person whose former partner controls a family trust, Caldwell confirms that the Court looks at who can control the trust and who can benefit, not only at who built the assets. For families who hold wealth in trusts, it shows that words in a deed about keeping assets for descendants do not protect the trust if one person is handed the power to control it and benefit from it.
The other guides in this series look at the decision from each of those positions.
Further reading
- Caldwell & Caldwell [2026] FedCFamC1A 81 (Full Court, 11 May 2026)
- Caldwell & Caldwell [2025] FedCFamC1F 506 (the decision appealed from)
- High Court of Australia — special leave refused, Caldwell v Caldwell [2026] HCADisp 215 (10 September 2026)
- Kennon v Spry [2008] HCA 56 (High Court)
- Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia — Property and finances overview
General information only. The right approach depends on your circumstances. Speak with a lawyer about advice specific to you.
Your next step
Talk it through with Daniel.
Daniel Brownlie is a family lawyer in Ballarat, assisting with property settlements, financial agreements, divorce and financial negotiations.
